Winning an Argument by Proving Him Wrong

In relationships, arguments are a fact of life. Whetherchecking out other women, he is probably cheating
you are dating or are married, it's statisticallyon her.
improbable that there would never once be an issue9. Since he's probably cheating on his marriage, he
that a husband and wife didn't see eye to eye on, orprobably never loved her and is just using her.
that there would never be any misunderstanding or a10. Therefore, they probably shouldn't be married
malfunction in communication between a boyfriendanymore.
and girlfriend. Any time two people spend timeI'd be willing to bet he might grant his wife the first
together, friction will occur no matter howthree at some point later in the argument (never at
harmonious the relationship is otherwise.first- that's just human nature), but the rest of the
The problem in winning an argument is that theaccusations get more and more bizarre. It becomes a
collateral damage to the relationship is not worth thechain of strange and indefensible logic, and it's a
small victory in having triumphed with superior logicalconstant attack against the husband and his integrity.
arguments. There are no winners when you win aBizarrely, his wife was probably just mad about how
battle but lose a war. Relationships are not abouthe didn't clean up after himself when using the
sides, and not about winning our losing. Relationshipsbathroom, and he hadn't realized it was important to
are based on cooperation and win-win situations.her, but the argument between this married couple
It's not a question of love or trust; communication indegenerated to the point of requiring a divorce
a relationship is a game of partial information. Mostlawyer.
forms of communication are short-hand, with aHowever, there are always two sides to the
heavy dependence upon prior assumptions thatequation. While the wife looks a bit ridiculous in this
back-fills in the details to provide a mutual frame ofargument, we haven't discussed the husband's
reference. However, assumption is the mother of allreactions to her polarized statements which keeps
mistakes, to heavily sanitize one of my catchphrases.egging the situation onward. While her husband also
Therefore, arguments and friction are bound to occurhas to share some of the blame in the situation, he
in marriages and dating relationships. They question isalso has to have awareness of what is happening
not whether a husband argues with his wife or aand why before he can begin to change the course
boyfriend argues with his girlfriend- the question isof the argument with his wife.
how the argument is resolved.The escalation of this argument is based in simple
There's is a natural tendency to polarize thehuman nature. When attacked, we defend ourselves.
argument when two people argue with each other.When the attack continues in spite of defense, we
Polarization is the rapid degeneration into extremecounterattack or run. Fight or Flight. Nature red in
statements that would normally be ridiculous if yourtooth and claw, and it's hardwired into us as part of
hackles weren't up "You don't EVER" and "Youour survival mechanisms.
ALWAYS" are the hallmarks of a polarized argument.Therefore, during the course of the argument, he
It also becomes a game of bizarre logic.probably had his own set of counterattacks and
An amusing example (at least if you're not currentlyarguments that were just as silly and ridiculous along
involved in a similar argument and have a slightedthe way, building up his own case against her. We
twisted sense of humor like me) would be this chaincould fill in the blanks easily from here; the
of logic, which is quite common in polarizedprogression once you see it is obvious.
arguments, which illustrates exactly how an argumentIt's very difficult to resolve these situations once
is won by proving him wrong:they start happening. It requires work to shut down
a polarized argument, and get to the real issue, and
1. The husband never leaves the toilet lid down.communicate how it makes you feel. But the first
2. He won't replace the toilet paper when he's usedstep is to understand why proving each other wrong
the last of it.is destructive, and to learn to recognize when this is
3. The husband never picks up the towels off thehappening.
floor.The fight has to be brought out of attack mode, and
4. The husband expects his wife to do everythingbrought down to a point where each person in the
for him.argument can begin to see and acknowledge the
5. Therefore, the husband is taking her for granted.other person's point of view even if they disagree.
6. Since he take her for granted and won't help out,It's the only way a win-win situation can be found
she's not important to him.that will resolve the real problem. No one will ever
7. She saw her husband drooling over the waitressconcede a polarized statement, and the argument
with the big breasts in the restaurant last week.has no other course of action but to continue to
8. Since he is taking his wife for granted, and isescalate.